News
Newsfeed
News
Thursday
March 28
Show news feed

The Venice Commisison has published the full text of the opinion adopted at the latest plenary session on the draft Judicial Code of Armenia.

According to the document, Armenia's draft judicial code implements positive changes brought by the constitutional reform and is generally compatible with European standards and the European best practices (with few exceptions discussed in the present opinion).

At the same time, it is an extremely long, detailed and complex document that would certainly benefit from simplification. Furthermore, it has a number of lacunas and inconsistencies, which need to be addressed, the Venice Commission said.

The Venice Commission  recommended to provide for a common sitting of all chambers of the Court of Cassation, in order to harmonise the case-law of different chambers and settle possible jurisdictional disputes.

Lower courts may be allowed to derogate from the established case law, but only if there are “strong arguments” justifying such departure and under control of the Court of Cassation. Incremental development of the case law by the courts should not be assimilated with the law-making, which is the prerogative of Parliament.

The Draft Code should define how the results of the written qualification exam are accounted in the process of recruitment of candidates.

Rules of conduct and duties of the judge should be formulated more precisely, preferably with reference to specific types of behaviour. The multitude of vague and overlapping formulas now contained in Articles 60 – 62 should be removed or merged into one general formula, which should be interpreted narrowly. 

Liability for inappropriate political engagement of the judges should be imposed within the framework of disciplinary proceedings and should be governed by the principle of proportionality. The Draft Code should provide for a possibility of appeal against decisions in disciplinary matters.

The Judicial Department may remain the central body performing administrative support functions vis-à-vis the courts, provided that its head is appointed by the Supreme Judicial Council and is answerable to it.

!
This text available in   Հայերեն and Русский
Print
Read more:
All
Armenia MP unanimously elected Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe subcommittee chairperson
Arusyak Julhakyan, a member of the majority Civil Contract Faction of the National Assembly of Armenia…
Loop around Azerbaijan or Aliyev regime is getting tighter, Armenia ambassador to Belgium says
The warnings given to Azerbaijan by the European Union (EU), and the developments at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) are the result of Azerbaijan's irresponsible and aggressive behavior…
Armenia MP at PACE: Council of Europe member countries must prosecute those who threaten or harm journalists
“The safety of journalists is not just a matter of individual rights, but a collective responsibility,” Arusyak Julhakyan stated in her address at the session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe…   
Azerbaijan decides to unofficially ‘scare’ Europe by leaving Council of Europe, its Parliamentary Assembly
Although it was noted at the PACE session Wednesday that the limitation of powers of the Azerbaijani delegation to the PACE does not mean the termination of Azerbaijan's participation in other organizations of the CoE, Baku's position is different, APA reported...
Dunja Mijatovic calls on Armenia, Azerbaijan to focus on human rights during their peace talks
The Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights…
PACE debating on limiting Azerbaijan delegation powers
One of the reasons is Baku's refusal to allow PACE rapporteurs into the Lachin corridor in 2023…
Photos